Jun 24 2008
Was Donovan McNabb right??
Daunte Culpepper and Byron Leftwich are both jobless as we approach training camp. How can this possibly be? Culpepper was once one of the better Quarterback’s in the NFL. And Leftwich, while not the greatest stats ever, was always a winner in Jacksonville.
Culpepper had one of the best years in NFL history with the Vikings in 2004, when he passed for 4,714 yards with 39 touchdowns and only 11 interceptions. And his career passer rating (89.9) rivals those of perennial Pro Bowlers Donovan McNabb and Carson Palmer. Mind you those are from years past, but there are too many David Carr’s and Mark Brunell’s on roster’s that makes you wonder why specifically Culpepper can’t get another shot.
Leftwich, who was in the same draft class as Kyle Boller also is still looking for work. So Kyle Boller is still on a roster and doesn’t have the careers stats or hasn’t shown the same leadership skills as Leftwich, but he is actually competing for a job. Leftwich does have a funky delivery and isn’t the most accurate passer, but how is he not in someone’s training camp competing for at least a backup job. He has shown the ability when in the right circumstance to be a winning quarterback and isn’t that what it’s all about.
When you look around and see the Casey Bramlets, Brooks Bollinger, Luke and Josh McCown and other assorted non descript quarterbacks still on rosters it makes you wonder why a former Pro Bowler like Culpepper doesn’t even get invited to a camp. Maybe Donovan McNabb was correct in his assessment of how the Black QB is still thought of in the league.
Backup quarterbacks are usually supposed to be cerebral and ready to play on a moments notice. Are Culpepper and Leftwich not thought to have those attributes? And what reason would that be? It would be difficult to maybe bring them into to a situation where you have a young starter who you don’t want looking over their shoulder. But you can’t tell me that if Todd Collins can come in a lead the Redskins on a five game run to the playoffs, Culpepper and Leftwich couldn’t offer that same kind of security blanket to some team. Todd Collins hadn’t started a game in 10 years when he came in for the Redskins last year. And yet both Culpepper and Leftwich started in the NFL last year.
They both were highly drafted quarterbacks and in Culpepper’s case highly successful. Someone, somewhere will have to tell me McNabb was wrong…

