Jul 28 2008
Packers Taking a Big Risk???
As this Brett Favre situation drags on and on I think what the hell are the Green Bay Packers doing. Mind you, I don’t mind seeing Favre get his, because the way he has gone back and forth with the Green Bay Packers the last couple of years has been selfish. And hey he did retire just a couple of months ago when the team was asking him to come back. But the one thing I can’t get out of my mind is that they were one interception away from going to the Super Bowl just 5 months ago. And no matter how good you think Aaron Rodgers will be, he may not be as ready to win now as the team is.
When the Bulls dynasty of the 90’s won their last title their general manager Jerry Reinsdorf famously said, “Organizations win championships.” While yes there is some truth in that statement. Winning does start from the top and works it’s way down. But I’ve seen over the years a lot of great owners who have never won a thing because they never had the players. Think about it if you could start a franchise would you rather start it with Bill Bellichek and Scott Piolo or Tom Brady. If you didn’t answer Brady stop reading this post.
The Bulls organization thought they could rebuild and recapture the magic and some 10 or so years later they haven’t. Building for the future should always be an integral part of any organization. But if you’re on the doorstep of championships you sometimes have to sacrifice the future for the right now. The future success isn’t always guaranteed. But putting Jordan, Rodman and Pippen back on the court would’ve guaranteed another chance at the 7th title.
This is why the Packer situation is so ridiculous. I’ve not bee a huge Farve fan these last couple of years, but he was clearly one of the 5-10 best QB’s in the league last year. And with him at quarterback you were one game away from the Super Bowl. In this era of free agency and holdouts and season ending injuries, I’d have to go with what I know. Aaron Rodgers could end up being the greatest quarterback in NFL History. I just don’t think he is a better option right now to take the Packers over the top.
The Packers can say we have a young team and we want that team to grow with Aaron Rodgers at quarterback. But realistically you have Al Harris and Charles Woodson up in age at corner. Having two lockdown corners in the NFL is something that doesn’t happen often. So right now you’re on the doorstep of going to the Super Bowl in the NFC. Yet, no matter how great Rodgers ends up being he more than likely will not play this year up to Favre’s current level. So right now I’m not worried about how many years Favre is going to play or whether this will retard Rodger’s progress. I just know at the most important position on the football field the Packers are going with a hope instead of something they know. If the Packers are saying they want to go with the best player at the position then the obvious choice is Favre.
This is different than the Steve Young Joe Montana situation. Through playing time gained through Montana’s injuries, Young had already proved to be a Pro Bowl level QB. It was hard to see Montana leave the 49ers, but it was made easier knowing what kind of player you had in Young. Rodgers has only proved he gets hurt a lot and he looked good for one half against the Cowboys last year.
I just hope Ted Thompson and Mike McCarthy are ready to deal with the fallout that will come if the Packers have a bad year whether Favre stays retired or not. And how their names and reputations are on the line based on Aaron Rodgers performance this year. At this point I’d much rather put mine on the line with Favre than Rodgers.
